Article
Res Gestae | Court Discusses MMA's Applicability, Standard or Review, and More in December
In December 2024, the Indiana Supreme Court decided four civil cases, while the Indiana Court of Appeals issued 13 published civil opinions.
A child and his parents filed a malpractice complaint against a hospital and physician, including a negligent-credentialing claim, after the physician sexually assaulted the child during a medical examination. The hospital settled, and plaintiffs sought excess compensation from the Patient’s Compensation Fund (PCF). The PCF moved for summary judgment, arguing the sexual assault or the hospital’s alleged negligence fell outside the Medical Malpractice Act’s (MMA) scope. The trial court denied the PCF’s motion, and the court affirmed in Ind. Dept. of Ins. v. Doe, 2024 WL 5199826 (Ind. Dec. 23, 2024). In doing so, the court addressed three issues of first impression, finding: (1) the PCF can challenge the MMA’s applicability after a plaintiff settles with a health care provider, as settlement only resolves factual questions of compensability, not legal questions; (2) negligent-credentialing claims only fall within the MMA if the credentialed physician commits medical malpractice; and (3) a physician’s sexual assault of a patient during a medical examination can constitute medical malpractice if it arises from an “inseparable part of the health care being rendered,” as it did in this case.
Click here to read the full article (starting on p. 35) written by Rani Amani, Jenny Buchheit, Abby DeMare, and Sean Dewey and first published in Res Gestae, an Indiana State Bar Association publication.
