Article

HR.Com | When the Investigation Is on Trial

September 2, 2026 – HR.Com
Catherine Strauss export image

Employers have long relied on workplace investigations to manage risk when facing allegations of harassment, discrimination, retaliation, or other misconduct. Yet a careful review of past litigation shows that the fact of conducting an investigation is no longer enough. At times, the investigation itself is on trial — scrutinized by attorneys, judges, and juries.

The stakes are real. In Mohamed v. Society for Human Resource Management, 2024 WL 5469056 (D. Colo. Oct. 8, 2024), a Colorado federal court denied summary judgment based partly on evidence questioning the integrity of the employer’s investigative process; the case went to trial and resulted in an $11.5 million verdict. The plaintiff’s theory was simple: the investigation was a sham, and the HR personnel supposedly investigating her complaints were simultaneously helping management build the case for her termination.

Read the full article written by Cathy Strauss published by HR.com.

Related People

Related Services & Industries

Related Categories

<p>Sign up now to receive periodic updates from Ice Miller&rsquo;s legal professionals.</p>

Sign up now to receive periodic updates from Ice Miller’s legal professionals.

Subscribe

Firm Highlights